By Lena MacDonald
The trees around the lake huddled together, the biting cold eclipsing any warmth from the sunlight glinting off the frozen surface. Through the window of the lodge, there was complete stillness. I often watched inquisitive squirrels and grunting moose from my chair, but they were conspicuous in their absence. Even the gently rippled ice was moving at too glacial a speed to be visible to my tired, leaden eyes. Sitting indoors was no fun for an old sea dog like me, more used to riding wild ocean waves than eschewing adventure. It was time to go.
Wrapped up warm against the weather, I stepped tentatively out onto the ice, my pack heavy against my spine. Raw skin prickled under microscopic snowflakes that whirled about in a sparkling blur. I didn’t dare go as far as the middle—the limnetic zone—where the ice would be at its thinnest and most dangerous. The ice was always fishing for men. I paused a third of the way out from the shore, testing the firmness of the freeze, and quickly set up my shanty, canvas chair, and rod. An automatic process after all these years.
Secured to my pack was an antique ice auger that had been my father’s. He was the true ice fishing expert, renowned in these parts for both his skill and his success. In comparison, I was nothing but an enthusiastic amateur: thirty years as captain of my own trawler couldn’t come close. Open-water fishing was too easy for him. I heard his voice, long gone from this world, telling me that with care, the auger would last even past my own lifetime. So, I treated it with reverence. It was also the only safe way to slice through the ice to the fish below. I kneeled down and prepared myself mentally.
The auger corkscrewed into the dense strata, my hands turning the handle clockwise cautiously, right hand over left, as rhythmic as a metronome. Round and round, nibbling downwards. With a wrenching motion, it broke through. I was jerked forward, my elbows slamming into the Baltic skin of the winter lake. A gush of gelid liquid spewed upwards, smelling of sludge and rot. I lay there, face framed by the freshly carved aperture, peering down into the crepuscular depths of the water. I exhaled slowly, issuing a silent prayer that the auger was still safely grasped in my gloved hands.
My bones ached from the sudden impact. A chill began to set in. I eased the auger out of the hole, placed it to one side, and sat back on my heels. Breathing slowly, I removed my gloves, peeling them gingerly from my fingers. Hands cupped to my face, warm exhalations invited the circulation to return until my digits were pink and no longer stiff. I rubbed my face vigorously, removing both the threat of frostbite on my nose and tiny icicles from my eyelashes.
Then the sound that every ice fisher dreads. A noise that, as my father had told me so many times, could mean death to a man caught in the wrong place at the wrong time. A sharp snap, followed by deep groan. The ice crackled below me. I settled slowly onto my stomach, limbs outstretched, trying—despite the bitter cold—to spread my weight evenly across the sheer film. A hairline fracture appeared, creeping towards me like a predator seeking a fresh kill. Other fissures followed, radiating out from the fresh void in the ice. I slithered in the direction of the shore, my fingers reaching for the refuge of solid ground, inch by tantalizing inch. The cracks in the ice followed me, chaperones on either side, before surging in front and uniting as one. I felt the ice heave, looming up in front of me, my weight off-center. The water began nipping at my toes, and then… the world fell away before me.
Gravity pulled me down the sloping ice, my prone form punching through the water and under the surface. Suspended and dazed, inhabiting a still and silent aquatic realm, I gazed in disbelief. The creeping chill soaked into my clothes. The sound of blood rushing in my head became a painful drumbeat, urging me to act—quickly!—before it was too late.
My body convulsed, goosebumps rising across my skin. Teeth chattered at a violent rate, trying to cleave my tongue in two. Limbs growing heavier, my sodden rain bibs and woolen thermals iron anchors, determined to reach the bottom. Kicking hard against their descent was futile resistance. I gasped for air, only to feel the piercing agony of frigid water entering my lungs. Tiny bubbles, all that was left of my breath, escaped my nostrils and streamed away in a bid for freedom from this cerulean world with its frosted roof. Even their gossamer trails had disappeared from view now, returning to the world above. They left me behind.
A solitary fish appeared in my field of view, swimming at funeral pace. It halted briefly, as if questioning why I was there, before proceeding on its way. Sinking further, I was consumed by gloom. My own private doldrums. The frigid torpor was almost gone: heart becalmed, body adrift. My feet landed on the lakebed first, heels digging into the dirt. Yellow Perch, I thought as I tilted backwards, relaxing onto the sandy chaise longue of the lakebed, a rock for a pillow.
As the shadows closed in, I stared upwards, unable even to blink. My world began to blur and darken, illuminated by the spotlight of a perfectly circular moon and scintillating stars twinkling through the rime-decorated glass ceiling. I felt safe. A short sleep would do me a world of good. If only that fish would stop swimming by.





Vividly written, this story will stick with me for a long time. Halfway through, I was so enthralled I forgot all about the theme of the month. Nicely done.
Thank you so much! You’ve made my day with that comment :D
Really vivid in detail! I found myself holding my breath in a panic. XD
Thank you Rose, I take that a massive compliment!
It didn’t dawn on me until I finished reading it that the title says “in” instead of “on”. Even though he seems pretty doomed to drown unless that fish has some magical powers, I can still hope.
Thank you Susan – never say never about magical fish :D
You have a beautiful way of describing the scene; very poetic.
Thank you Arlan! I’m so pleased you think that :D
Wow! I too found myself holding my breath. A beautiful and horrible story, thank you for sharing!
PS The last line is my favorite.
‘Beautiful and horrible’ made me laugh, but I’m so glad you like the fish!
Eerily vivid descriptions… almost reminds me of ‘To Build a Fire’
Thank you Zachary for your comment and also for the story recommendation! I’ve not read it before but I’ll take a look!
I remember reading that story in school. I hated it. But I enjoyed this piece a lot.
Ahhh! Chills! I would ask if you’ve drowned at the bottom of a frozen lake before, but I should know the answer to that. Well done!
Thank you so much for your comment! :D
“Ice was always fishing for men.”–my favorite line. I should’ve known how it would end then.
Thank you so much AMediting! I love that line too :)
Stunning story, full of chilling descriptions and a cracking ending!
Puntastic! Thank you :)
This was a fab story. I could feel myself being drawn into it and when the ice noise started I genuinely began to be concerned. Sign of a top author!
Thank you so much Nik! What a wonderful compliment! :D
Poetically written and rich in detail. Perfectly realised. As others have said, this story will stay with me for a long time. Great flash!
Thank you Kirsti! I’ll take ‘poetically written’ :D
The chilly rhythms capture the essence of the story. The memories piercing the now and having no impact on decisions being taken in the characters now.
Excellent short story as you read you feel the movements and actions of the narrator.
The turning point captured in a few well chosen words . ‘A sharp snap, followed by deep groan.’
A tale that works on many levels.
Thank you so much Liz! I’m so glad you like the turning point :)
Vivid details and what an ending! Love the last line about the fish.
Thank you Caroline! The fish was actually cut from one of the drafts, but I’m glad I brought it back :)
“The ice was always fishing for men.” Fabulous line in a fabulous story!! Gorgeous descriptions and a brilliant last line!
Wonderful. Brilliant. I have read this story over and over. I can see it happening, hear it happening and feel it happening. Completely captivating. So well written.
Fabulous story, full of gripping detail. Loved it.
chilling in a very different sense of the word – an enthralling look at a different world perfectly conjured up. The ice world is very vividly drawn and I felt as if I was in the fisherman’s boots right to the finale.
So well written, you have descriptive writing nailed. I could picture it perfectly while trying to predict the ending, which was ghastly and not what I expected. You dragged me in. Now I’m off to warm up!
Now I’m freezing. Not my usual reading but couldn’t stop once started. Your descriptive writing captured my interest right from the start. Very well written.
I very much enjoyed reading this story. It was very descriptive, I felt like I was watching a film, vivid! Well written, gripping and a moving ending – excellent!
Beautifully crafted, haunting and strangely reassuring story!
Wow! A gripping tale. Also loved the word choices, especially “swimming at funeral pace”. Really enjoyed it!
Loved the slow, tense buildup. The description is chilling (pun intended) and the use of first person gives us false hope the narrator will survive the ordeal. Tense and compelling.
Wonderfully vivid, I loved this!
This is a gripping read Helen. Really enjoyed another opportunity to read it.
Wonderfully atmospheric, great tension in this story!
I’ve read this a few times now, it’s very atmospheric. I keep coming back to the line ‘The ice was always fishing for men.’ And so peaceful at the end, despite the outcome.
Loved this tense and atmospheric story. The description takes you right there and the little details like father’s auger, the fish and the cracking of the ice build the tension slowly, with the reader still hoping he’s going to get out of this, somehow..
“The ice was always fishing for men” is a great line. Very atmospheric.
A wonderful story, with a great twist. Some incredible scenesetting and imagination of the physical environment.
“The sound that every ice fisher dreads” really gripping and the end strangely beautiful.
This is brilliantly atmospheric Helen and you build up the tension and drama fantastically. I totally became lost in the story.
A beautifully written story. Dark, cold and gripping to the end. Well done, Helen.
This is wonderfully atmospheric! The juxtaposition of the panic and the calm is beautifully done.
The building of tension in this piece is great. A gripping read
Fantastic and horrifying!
I looked at this story and thought… all those paragraphs. No dialog. How can this be interesting or thrilling? And yet it was both. Very well done. Enthralling.