By Hannah Carter
You canβt eat morals. This motto had earned Abraham quite the reputation across town, meaning many shady characters ended up in his tent on darkened nights. When the work Abraham had done for his clients tormented his mind, he told himself one thing.
Scruples didnβt stave off starvationβmoney did.
And the fellow in front of him held a bag full of it, enough to feed Abraham for weeks.
Abraham shifted forward, his legs crossed as he sat on the floor. βSo all I need to do is find this pregnant woman and kill her.β
The stranger, swathed in amaranthine-colored clothes and jewels, reclined against a cushion. He toyed with a silver coin, staring at Abraham with dark, hooded eyes. βPrecisely. A teenage girl, need I remind you. Barely grown. A man like yourself should have no problem taking care of myβ¦ issue. Not to mention the location is idealβa stable on the outside of town.β
Abraham imagined the face of a girl his sisterβs age and winced. Noβstop. He didnβt care who this teenage girl wasβa jilted lover, a disobedient daughter, an unfaithful wife. And he certainly was in no position to judge an adult man who wanted her dead, either. This stranger might have been paying for the knife, but Abraham was the one who would drive it through her heart. βAll right. What do you want as proof that the job is done?β
A thin smile curved the manβs lips. βOh, Iβll have ways of knowing when sheβs dead.β He tossed the bag of thirty coins to Abraham, and a few spilled onto the ground. The strangerβs voice turned prickly, like thorns in a garden. βBut if you break our agreement, Iβll have you arrested and crucified for all your sins.β
Abraham stuffed the fallen silver pieces back into the leather bag. βIβll do it tonight.β
Abraham hated crowds, and right now the town bustled with people due to the census. Crowds typically meant witnesses, which made Abrahamβs work harder. But he could also use it to his advantage. No one would notice if a slip of a girl and her unwanted baby went missing. Every relative would just assume she was with someone else until they realized the truth. Even then, they may not suspect her dead.
He coughed, an attempt to loosen the lump in his throat.
Iβve killed before. Lots of times. Never cared before if they were guilty or innocent.
Another strangled cough.
Itβs one more personβs blood on my hands. Who they are doesnβt matter.
Sand collected on Abrahamβs sandals as he followed the manβs instructions to a stable on the outskirts of town. A star blazed brightly overhead, illuminating the path before him.
His grip tightened on his knife as he neared. No sound drifted from the large house up on the hill, the closest residence. All the candles had been blown out for the night.
Something snapped in the bushes behind him.
He whirled around and threw the knife at the sound with practiced accuracy. Whatever lurked there died with a quiet bleat, and Abraham raced over to findβ
A lamb.
Cursing his nerves, he yanked the knife out of the lambβs side. Some shepherd would be punished for that, surely. And if it somehow got traced back to Abrahamβ¦
No, impossible. It was one sheep. In a huge flock, would one even be noticed?
Abraham swallowed, though the action felt like heβd stabbed himself in the esophagus. He hacked and wiped his mouth, but the pain didnβt lessen.
One stupid sheep. One stupid teenage girl. One stupid lump in his throat choking him.
He wanted this job to be over.
The barn was a few yards away now. He crept toward it, muscles tense. The star in the sky seemed to burn brighter, like a second, watchful moon with its eye on him.
A girlβs cry shattered his nerves.
No! She couldnβt give birth now. That would draw attention. Someone might come checkβ
He dashed to the stable, but by the time he got there, a second wail joined the first. Knife poised for the kill, Abraham burst inside, his only thought to silence the mother and newborn. But instead, he dropped to his knees.
The girl lay on a bedroll, propped up on hay. A man crouched beside her, his arm around her shoulders, one hand protectively placed against an infant. And the baby himselfβ¦
The emotional dam that had strangled Abraham all night exploded as he glimpsed the infantβs face. There was nothing extraordinary about the childβthe babe was quite plain, covered in afterbirthβbut when he turned his eyes upon Abraham, the rest of the world faded away.
The babeβs eyes had only opened for a second, seeing the world for the first time. So how, when they met Abrahamβs, did they carry the weight of the world in them? How did they pierce him from across the stable, expose all the blood on his hands, and strew his sins across the room like the straw? But this newborn child carried no condemnation in his eyes.
Abrahamβs grip on his knife slipped, the blade still covered in the blood of the lamb.
Had he ever known peace until heβd seen those eyes?
βWho are you?β the man asked, his voice gruff, the reverent moment destroyed. He rose halfway to his feet, his face red. βWhatβs your business here?β
βIββ Abraham fought to loosen his tongue.
The girl placed her hand against the man. She glanced knowingly at the knife before she offered Abraham a tired smile. βItβs okay, Joseph. I think weβll have all sorts of visitors tonight.β She adjusted the infant in her arms. βWould you like to come meet Yeshua?β
The glow of the star poured through the windows, shafts falling on the infantβs head.
βYes,β Abraham whispered.
Peace.
Outside the stable, Abraham could have sworn he heard singing.





Such an unexpected retelling. Beautifully done.
Thank you so much! I knew when I saw the theme that I had to write about the most legendary event I knew. π
A beautiful story. Loved the perspective!
Thank you so much, Tracy! I enjoyed writing from Abraham’s POV. π
Wow. This gave me chills. Beautifully written, beautiful twist on a familar story, just plain all around beautiful. And the perfect story for this perfect day.
Thank you so much, Rosemarie! I’m so glad that you enjoyed it. Christmas is the most legendary event the world has ever known. π
Powerful words and such detail.. makes you feel as though you are walking with Abraham as he makes his trek to kill. Love all the ways you weave Biblical aspects into the story π
Thank you so much, Melodie! I had a lot of fun trying to weave in all the Biblical aspects that I wanted to get in. π
powerful and beautiful!
Thank you so much, Laurie! I appreciate it. π
This was beautiful, Hannah, like so many of your stories. I read through Isaiah 53 yesterday, which encapsulates why Jesus came even though not your traditional Christmas reading. Ironically, you even have a couple phrases from that chapter in your story. Thank you for this unique perspective on an event we celebrate every year.
Thank you so much, Arlan! You are always so supportive with all my–and everyone’s!–stories. I appreciate you so much! π
There are so many prophecies that tend to get overlooked when talking about Christmas. It seems we always read the Nativity story–which is beautiful, of course!–but if you look at the history, at the prophecies, it’s so awe-inspiring. God is truly the best Author that there is–there are so many threads woven throughout time in the Bible!
You gave me goosebumps! Excellent tale! β€οΈ
Thank you so much, Rose! I am so glad you enjoyed it. I hope you had a wonderful Christmas! π
This was a wonderfully written story, and a great perspective to follow. As you follow him, you can understand all the fears and thoughts going through Abrahamβs head, and in the end you can feel the peace that he felt when he laid eyes on the baby! Such a beautiful ending to this story!! π₯Ή You have such an extraordinary talent, Hannah!! π
Thank you so much, Andrew! I am glad that you enjoyed. Thanks for reading! π