By J. M. Allison
I hefted my dadβs old army binoculars back into position and scanned the yard for our target. No one wanted to acknowledge the truth, but the facts were undeniable.
βHow long we gotta keep this up, Mikey? Itβs cold up here, and we only got the one binoculars.β Calvin rubbed his mitten-covered hands together and scowled from behind the coils of his knitted scarf.
I let the binoculars fall against my puffy coat and pinned the guys with a hard stare. βOld lady Caperelli is a Mafia hitman. If you donβt wanna help me prove it, then leave.β
Calvin chewed his lower lip, and Albiβs eyes grew wide. Theyβd sworn to help uncover the truth. Backing out now was akin to refusing a triple-dog-dare. Theyβd be labeled cowards forever.
βHowβre you gonna prove it?β Albi leaned forward, his glasses giving him an owlish look.
βIβve been gatherinβ evidence.β I pulled a tattered notebook from under the scattered comics, candy wrappers, and action figures littering the floor of the treehouse and flipped through it till I found the right page.
βShe called Mr. Beghetti an over-stuffed, puffed-up turkey,β I pointed to where Iβd transcribed my evidence. βThen she said he better listen, or heβd be sorry since his health was a fragile thing. Two months later, she bragged to my mom about having taken care of him with one shot.β Albiβs eyes grew wider. Calvin gulped audibly. βNo oneβs seen poor Mr. Beghetti since.β
βThatβs not real evidence.β Calvin pushed his chin out. βBesides, my mom said he just retired.β
I scowled. βWhat do you think it means when the mob says theyβre retirinβ you?β I drew a finger across my throat.
βThatβs true.β Albi turned unblinking eyes toward Calvin. βMy brother saw it in a movie.β
The tired rumble of Ms. Caperelliβs station wagon caught our attention, and we ducked out of sight. We listened as she pulled into the drive and shuffled around, muttering to herself.
βCanβt believe taking off the head was so messyβ¦ Heβs too big to fit insideβ¦ Iβll stash him in the chest freezer.β
We peeked over the windowsill to see her prod the corners of the tarp filling her trunk. If only I could get a closer look. I inched the binoculars into position.
βMorning, Ms. Caperelli!β my momβs voice interrupted, and we ducked back down.
βGood morning, Jill.β Ms. Caperelliβs voice held only sweetness and innocence.
βAny Thanksgiving plans?β I pictured my mom in her oversized sweater, leaning over the short white fence between our drive and Ms. Caperelliβs yard, chatting, a teal headband in her big curly hair.
βTaking care of a few neighborhood problems then getting ready for the next job.β
Images flashed through my mind of Ms. Caperelli cruising the streets in her brown station wagon, spraying lead from a tommy gun out the window at the neighborhood bullies, then cleaning an array of machine guns, brass knuckles, and knives.
βWeβd love to have you join us tonight!β
The guysβ heads snapped up, their faces a mix of pity and terror. My gut squeezed. Mom had just invited Ms. Caperelli over for Thanksgiving dinner!
βSounds lovely,β Ms. Caperelli chirped. βIβll see you tonight.β
βPerfect.β I heard the smile in my momβs voice. Then the smile disappeared. βMikey, time to come in, and donβt forget to pull up the trash bins.β
βWellβ¦β Calvin didnβt meet my eyes. βSee ya tomorrow, Mikey.β He scrambled from the treehouse like a cat dragging a tin can.
βGood luck, Mikey!β Albi chimed in as he clambered after Calvin.
I chewed my lower lip. The need for proof had just become critical. If she realized I was onto her, Iβd be next on her hitlist. Sheβd take me out before Mom served the mashed potatoes.
I couldnβt wait. No easy options. I crawled to the ladder and peeped out.
Ms. Caperelli was nowhere in sight. I scrambled out of the treehouse and raced for the safety of the house. Then I skidded to a stop. The trash bins! Mom would kill me before Ms. Caperelli got the chance.
I raced back down the drive.
βAh, young Michael.β
My blood ran cold. I froze and turned to face the wrinkliest and deadliest woman in the neighborhood.
βWould you help me carry him to my freezer?β She gestured toward her trunk.
She wanted me to help her hide the body! Excitement and terror crawled down my spine. If I helped, Iβd have undeniable proof. Then again, she might retire me to ensure I couldnβt snitch on her.
I forced one foot in front of the other as I walked toward the trunk.
βYouβre such a strong boy, Iβm sure youβll manage. Iβll get the doors for you.β She turned to lead the way.
With trembling fingers, I pulled back the tarp to find a large round package sitting in the corner. The brown paper wrapping bore reddish smudges, and dark feathery hair-like whisps clung to the edge of the paper.
I was right. She had a severed head in here!
I gingerly picked up the parcel. It was heavier than Iβd expected. I had my evidence. I turned to run for home, but I only managed two steps before my foot hit ice. I found myself sprawled on the driveway, my precious evidence flying through the air.
It hit the ground and tumbled from its wrappings. I stared at the fresh body she intended to stash in her fridge. A huge turkey body.
βNo worries, dear,β Ms. Caperelli called from inside the garage. βItβll taste just fine once I cook it. I love getting my turkey fresh from the farm. A bit more work and mess, but worth it. Hereβs a little thank you for your help.β
I looked up as she hobbled forward, a kind smile lighting her face, and a twenty-dollar bill in her hand. The guys would never believe me. I smiled back. Sometimes a sweet old lady was just a sweet old lady.


(6 votes, average: 2.50 out of 3)


great twist! happy thanksgiving π¦!
Thanks for reading! Happy Turkey Day to you as well. π
This holiday tale has the nostalgia of “A Christmas Story.” Thank you for this Thanksgiving treat.
Thank you! I’m honored you would consider my story in the same vain as such a classic. π
Instead of expressing concern that Michael might have hurt himself in his fall, Ms. Caperelli first thought is for the turkey…
Just what I’d expect from a psychopathic mafia hitwoman
She pays well for his silence. π
She’s paying him to fuhgeddaboudit!! TOTAL MAFIA π€£π€£π€£
I love the boys ‘ overactive imaginations!
They imagined a lot more elaborate things, but you can only fit so much in 1000 words. π I’m glad you enjoyed the story.
So much fun to read!! Gotta love the hilarious imaginations of little kids. Happy Thanksgiving!!
Fun story!
This was great!
What a nice, respectful boy. He’ll make a fine member of “The Family”. π€£π€£π€£