By Pamela Love
In Vermont, we call the spring thaw Mud Season, a time of year that gives new meaning to the word battleground, for itâs necessary to battle the ground simply to walk. Either you struggle while the muck sucks at your shoes and even skirts if they arenât hitched up a bit, or you tumble when itâs too slick, which causes the unwary much irritation.
One late-March morning, I made my way through the muckâwith difficultyâto the little red schoolhouse where Iâd taught for twenty years. Beside its steps crouched a boy I didnât recognize, about eight years old, gazing at that omnipresent March mud. Either heâs dropped something or made a discovery. I gave him a welcoming smile, hoping to start his time at my school off on a good foot. âGood morning. Iâm Miss Morgan, the teacher. Whatâs your name?â
âAsh Forester, miss.â He barely glanced at me before turning his attention back to the mud.
ForesterâI didnât know any family in town by that name, but by the looks of it, they needed help; on a day when I was shivering despite my woolen shawl, Ash wore threadbare shirt and trousers. Worse still, his feet were bare. While most folks around here âdonât hold with taking charity,â tact will usually persuade them to accept hand-me-downs. And it was a good sign Ashâs parents sent their freckle-faced son to school willingly, since they werenât keeping him at home to do chores instead of allowing him to get an education.
I started up the steps. âCome inside, Ash.â There was a mat to wipe his feet on and a stove to warm them, once Iâd built that morningâs fire.
When he didnât follow, I turned to see him glancing up, his brow furrowed. âIâm busy, miss.â
I raised my eyebrows. âBusy doing what?â
He didnât answer, just chewed his lower lip while staring at that wretched mud. No worm or any other small creature that children seem to find so fascinating could be seen by his toes. Perhaps heâs dropped something. It canât be a lunch pailâeven Vermont mud couldnât have swallowed that, though not for want of trying! I suppressed a chuckle. âAsh, I asked you a question; youâre busy doing what?â
He sighed. âI seed, miss.â
I encourage my pupilsâ interest in nature for the most part, although I do not share it. I descended the steps and bent over him. âOh, you saw something, did you? What was it?â
He swung around, his face red with indignation. âI never saw, ever, miss. I seed.â
I sucked in my breath to reprimand him, but decided against it for there was no insolence in his manner. He truly thought that âseedâ was the correct past tense of the verbâdoubtless because heâd heard it that way at home. It made me think this was quite likely his first day of school, ever.
However, I believe in beginning as one means to go on. âYou are coming to school, Ash. Your first and most important lesson is not to contradict the teacher.
âYour second lesson is that âsawâ is the correct word to use. For example, you could have said, âI saw a flower.ââ He shook his head, hard. I held up a forefinger, as I had countless times before. âOr beetle, pebble, or whatever it happened to be. Repeat after me: I saw aââ
âNo, miss. I never saw anythinâ. Or hew, chop, or cut.â He tapped his chest. âI seed. Oh, and this oneâs a-cominâ. Step back, miss!â With frog-like agility, he leapt aside.
Hew, chop, or cutâŚThis boy truly did not understand what I was trying to impart, but perhaps I, too, was misinterpreting his meaning?  Nevertheless, I could not permit such impudence. I folded my arms. âAsh, you must speak to a teacher with courtesyââ
âBut miss! See there?â He pointed downward to where tiny brown bubbles were popping.
Just then, a full-grown tree well-nigh shot up from the ground, its crimson-budded branches smacking me in the face. I stumbled back, slipped, and fell, landing on my bustle in that maddening mud.
Ash laughed. âNow you see, miss? I seed.â With a laugh, he trotted off into the forest, his skin becoming more and more green with every step.
Gritting my teeth, I sat up, shaking the muck from my gloves. ââSowâ would have been a more appropriate choice of words!â I called after him, though I had to admit to myself that seed could be used as a verb.
I hurried home at an unladylike pace to change, knowing that I had made a muddle of that entire encounter. Nevertheless, while some may think me old-fashioned, I believe children should be seen and not seed!





As a teacher, I thoroughly enjoyed this story!
I’m a former teacher myself. Glad you liked it!
Fun word play!
Thanks! I often use word play in my stories.
My family has a long history in Vermont, although I no longer live there.
What a fun story! See, saw, seed. Love it!
Thanks so much!
What a delightful story!
I appreciate the compliment!
A fun imaginative trip back to the days when our Grandfather was a boy in Vermont, before he made his way westward to Michigan.đ¤
Though presumably he wasn’t magically growing trees!
Creative! Thank you for sharing :)